Try our mobile app

Operating update

Published: 2023-05-09 09:39:41 ET
<<<  go to JSE:SSW company page
SIBANYE STILLWATER LIMITED
(SIBANYE-STILLWATER)
Incorporated in the Republic of South Africa
Registration number 2014/243852/06
Share code: SSW and SBSW
Issuer code: SSW
ISIN: ZAE000259701

OPERATING UPDATE

QUARTER ENDED 31 MARCH 2023

Johannesburg, 9 May 2023: Sibanye Stillwater Limited (Sibanye-Stillwater or the Group) (JSE: SSW and NYSE: SBSW) is pleased to provide an
operating update for the quarter ended 31 March 2023 (Q1 2023). The Group's financial results are only provided on a six-monthly basis.

SALIENT FEATURES - QUARTER ENDED 31 MARCH 2023 COMPARED TO QUARTER ENDED 31 MARCH 2022 (Q1 2022)

- Safety statistics improve further as Fatal elimination strategy progresses
- Green metals strategy advances
   - Keliber lithium refinery construction commenced - Finnish Minerals Group partner supports rights issue and confirmed to increase
     shareholding to 20%
   - Rhyolite Ridge JV receives support from United States Department of Energy through conditional US$700 million loan
   - Successful takeover offer for New Century Resources enhances our circular economy exposure
- Strategic diversification and growth mitigates against challenging macroeconomic and regional operating environment
  - Group generated an adjusted EBITDA of R7.8 billion (US$441 million) in Q1 2023
     - SA gold operations return to profitability following a recovery from industrial action, appropriate wage agreement and higher gold price
     - SA PGM operations impacted by pull back in PGM prices and localised operational challenges
     - Shaft incident at US PGM underground operations temporarily delays repositioning progress
     - Recycling throughput down due to low vehicle scrapping with improving outlook as new auto sales show signs of recovery
- Group liquidity enhanced through successful refinancing and increase of the US$ revolving credit facility to US$1 billion

           US dollar                                                                                                           SA rand
         Quarter ended                                       KEY STATISTICS                                                 Quarter ended
Mar 2022 Dec 2022 Mar 2023                                       GROUP                                             Mar 2023   Dec 2022    Mar 2022
     898       573       441   US$m                         Adjusted EBITDA(1)                            Rm          7,824     10,095      13,664
   15.22     17.61     17.76   R/US$            Average exchange rate using daily closing rate

                                                               AMERICAS REGION
                                                           PGM underground operations
 122,389   105,205   100,690   oz                         2E PGM production(2),(3)                         kg         3,132       3,272       3,807
   2,058     1,738     1,426   US$/2Eoz                   Average basket price                         R/2Eoz        25,326      30,608      31,323
     139        80        14   US$m                           Adjusted EBITDA(1)                           Rm           254       1,414       2,112
   1,244     1,852     1,861   US$/2Eoz                    All-in sustaining cost(4)                   R/2Eoz        33,052      32,613      18,940
                                                               US PGM recycling
 190,871    95,881    78,844   oz                          3E PGM recycling(2),(3)                        kg          2,452       2,982       5,937
   3,061     3,132     2,972   US$/3Eoz                   Average basket price                        R/3Eoz         52,783      55,157      46,588
      17        17        11   US$m                           Adjusted EBITDA(1)                          Rm            199         305         263

                                                        SOUTHERN AFRICA (SA) REGION
                                                                PGM operations
 410,848   411,515   379,791   oz                         4E PGM production(3),(5)                        kg         11,813      12,800      12,779
   2,961     2,382     2,051   US$/4Eoz                   Average basket price                        R/4Eoz         36,433      41,953      45,061
     798       491       391   US$m                           Adjusted EBITDA(1)                          Rm          6,952       8,651      12,140
   1,175     1,233     1,129   US$/4Eoz                    All-in sustaining cost(4)                  R/4Eoz         20,043      21,713      17,886
                                                                Gold operations
 137,091   224,187   200,267   oz                            Gold production                               kg        6,229        6,973       4,264
   1,873     1,716     1,864   US$/oz                      Average gold price                            R/kg    1,064,302      971,623     916,351
    (45)        21        44   US$m                           Adjusted EBITDA(1)                           Rm          774          371       (680)
   2,420     1,839     1,826   US$/oz                      All-in sustaining cost(4)                     R/kg    1,042,868    1,041,218   1,183,944

                                                              EUROPEAN REGION
                                                 Battery metals - Sandouville refinery(6)
   1,646       624     1,609   tNi                          Nickel production(7)                         tNi          1,609         624       1,646
  31,462    31,649    28,258   US$/tNi           Nickel equivalent average basket price(8)             R/tNi        501,856     557,348     478,856
     (6)      (17)      (14)   US$m                         Adjusted EBITDA(1)                            Rm          (245)       (307)        (89)
  35,221    63,503    38,750   US$/tNi              Nickel equivalent sustaining cost(9)                R/tNi       688,196   1,118,280      536,070

(1) The Group reports adjusted earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) based on the formula included in the
    facility agreements for compliance with the debt covenant formula. Adjusted EBITDA may not be comparable to similarly titled measures of
    other companies. Adjusted EBITDA is not a measure of performance under IFRS and should be considered in addition to and not as a substitute
    for other measures of financial performance and liquidity. For a reconciliation of profit/(loss) before royalties and tax to adjusted EBITDA,
    see "Adjusted EBITDA reconciliation - Quarters"
(2) The US PGM operations' underground production is converted to metric tonnes and kilograms, and performance is translated to SA rand (rand).
    In addition to the US PGM operations' underground production, the operation treats recycling material which is excluded from the 2E PGM
    production, average basket price and All-in sustaining cost statistics shown. PGM recycling represents palladium, platinum, and rhodium
    ounces fed to the furnace
(3) The Platinum Group Metals (PGM) production in the SA operations is principally platinum, palladium, rhodium and gold, referred to as 4E
    (3PGM+Au), and in the US operations is principally platinum and palladium, referred to as 2E (2PGM) and US PGM recycling is principally
    platinum, palladium and rhodium referred to as 3E (3PGM)
(4) See "Salient features and cost benchmarks - Quarters" for the definition of All-in sustaining cost (AISC)
(5) The SA PGM production excludes the production associated with the purchase of concentrate (PoC) from third parties. For a reconciliation
    of the production including third party PoC, refer to the "Reconciliation of operating cost excluding third party PoC for Total US and
    SA PGM, Total SA PGM and Marikana - Quarters"
(6) Sibanye-Stillwater Sandouville Refinery (Sandouville Refinery) results for the quarter ended March 2022 include the two months since
    acquisition (4 February 2022)
(7) The nickel production at the Sandouville refinery operations is principally nickel metal and nickel salts (liquid form), together referred
    to as nickel equivalent products
(8) The nickel equivalent average basket price per tonne is the total nickel revenue adjusted for other income less non-product sales divided
    by the total nickel equivalent tonnes sold
(9) See "Salient features and cost benchmarks - Quarters, Sibanye-Stillwater Sandouville Refinery" for a reconciliation of cost of sales
    before amortisation and depreciation to nickel equivalent sustaining cost

Stock data for the quarter ended 31 March 2023                   JSE Limited - (SSW)
Number of shares in issue                                        Price range per ordinary share (High/Low)                    R36.53 to R51.68
- at 31 March 2023                               2,830,567,264   Average daily volume                                               11,934,816
- weighted average                               2,830,407,465   NYSE - (SBSW); one ADS represents four ordinary shares
Free Float                                                 99%   Price range per ADS (High/Low)                           US$7.91 to US$12.31
Bloomberg/Reuters                                 SSWSJ/SSWJ.J   Average daily volume                                               3,816,168

OVERVIEW FOR THE QUARTER ENDED 31 MARCH 2023 COMPARED TO QUARTER ENDED 31 MARCH 2022

The Group safety performance for Q1 2023, built on the significantly improved safety delivery for 2022, which represented the best safety
performance in the Group's history. This was a motivating factor during a challenging period which was characterised by significant
global economic risk and uncertainty, ongoing geopolitical developments and localised operational challenges.

Contrary to the previous expectations of a deep global recession, market commentators had generally become more positive at the
beginning of 2023, although the prognosis for the global macro economic environment remained unpredictable. With the US Federal
Reserve continuing to raise interest rates and persistent inflation, and an anticipated economic recovery from China yet to fully
materialise following the termination of the zero COVID-19 policy, the intensity and duration of a probable global recession remains
uncertain. This contributed to a significant retreat in global markets and commodity prices, with only the traditional energy commodities
and those associated with future green energy generation remaining relatively resilient. Gold also bucked the trend, with the dollar gold
price breaching record highs in May 2023, which underpinned its status as a hedge against uncertainty.

With the imperative of combatting climate change attracting continued increased intensity, security of supply of critical minerals is
becoming a top national priority for many governments with active support building for the establishment of local and regional value
chains. New supportive regulatory frameworks and incentive programmes have been introduced in North America and Europe, as such,
critical metals necessary for the green energy transition and innovative energy storage systems requiring a broader range of minerals will
become increasingly important.

Heightened global risks and material macroeconomic challenges, including elevated energy prices, weak economic growth and
persistent inflationary pressures, as well as regional challenges, such as the increasing risks associated with the ongoing decline of the
South African State energy provider, Eskom, and increasing levels of organised crime confirmed the appropriateness and necessity of
continuing with our ongoing strategic evolution that supports attainment of our purpose "to safeguard global sustainability through our
metals".

Our strategic growth and diversification is positioning us to navigate these challenges, and, through our disciplined approach to capital
allocation, we have continued to strengthen our financial position and credit rating. The recent refinancing of our Revolving Credit Facility
(RCF) which was increased from US$600 million to US$1 billion with strong support from a syndicate of global banks, has further enhanced
our liquidity and financial flexibility, thus providing strategic optionality for new opportunities for growth and diversification aligned with our
strategy.
In this regard, we continued to advance our green metals strategy during Q1 2023 with the construction of the Keliber lithium refinery
commencing in March 2023. As part of a previously announced rights issue to secure the outstanding equity funding for the Keliber lithium
project, the Finnish Minerals Group (which manages the Finnish State's mining industry shareholdings), announced that it will increase its
holding in the Keliber project from 14% to 20%, by subscribing for EUR53.9 million (R1 billion) of the EUR104 million (R2 billion) rights issue.
With the initial equity funding of the project capital already secured through the increase of Sibanye-Stillwater's shareholding to over 50%, and the
balance of the target equity funding secured through the planned rights issue of about EUR104 million, the remaining project capital will be
raised through debt finance. Supply of regionally produced lithium into the European green energy ecosystem is a key strategic
advantage, and the competitive positioning of this project with its strong ESG credentials, is set to deliver the greenest primary lithium into
European markets.

The acquisition of Sandouville which was concluded in Q1 2022, is another key component of our strategic growth in Europe. Sandouville,
together with our investment in Keliber, has resulted in significant recognition by the the Finnish and French governments and the
European Union of our commitment to providing Europe with climate change solutions, aligned with our purpose.

In the interim we continue to ensure an undercapitalised plant at Sandouville remains operational and continues to build up production
to nameplate capacity. The ongoing restructuring and integration of the Sandouville nickel refinery has resulted in improved performance
during Q1 2023 compared to Q1 2022, despite elevated energy costs and industrial unrest in France, which disrupted industry nationwide.
A number of commercial initiatives are underway to adjust product mix to align with market requirements with a view to improving
profitability.

We are also progressing studies to unlock the potential of Sandouville. The Sandouville site is earmarked as the base to establish our
European autocatalyst recycling operations. By leveraging our extensive PGM recycling knowledge and experience from our US
operations, we are well positioned to grow our recycling presence in Europe, further enhancing our exposure to the circular economy
and supplying some of the greenest metals globally. The PGM recycling project feasibility study is expected to be complete at the end of
2023. A feasibility study is expected to be completed by end of 2024 on production of nickel sulphate as a battery precursor. The nickel
sulphate plant is expected to be developed with battery recycling in mind to occupy a nodal position in this important emerging market
opportunity in Europe through a world leading facility.

We also reinforced our position in tailings waste retreatment through a successful takeover bid for New Century Resources Limited in
March 2023. A positive response to the bid from New Century shareholders has increased our shareholding from 19.9% to more than 95.5%,
with compulsory acquisition of the remaining minority shareholders underway. The total consideration for the incremental 80.1% is US$83
million (A$120 million) based on the offer price on a fully diluted basis. This acquisition builds international exposure for the Group's tailings
retreatment business, complementing our existing investment in DRDGOLD and enhancing our ability to deliver some of the greenest
metals globally.

Our exposure to the US battery industry through our investment in ioneer and the Rhyolite Ridge project made positive progress during the
period, with ioneer receiving a conditional loan of up to US$700 million from the US Department of Energy during the quarter. This is a
positive indication of support for the project, primarily due to its competitive position in the region, which supports our strategic focus on
selected regional ecosystems.

The increasingly supportive environment in Europe is in stark contrast to the operating environment in South Africa, which has continued to
regress, as reflected in the Fraser Institute Annual Survey of Mining Companies 2022, where it ranked in the bottom ten global mining
jurisdictions for the second year and ranked 57 out of 62 countries in the overall Investment Attractiveness Index.

The deteriorating quality of public services and increase in organised criminal activity in South Africa has become an increasing risk.
Eskom's decreasing energy availability factor is having a major impact on the South African economy and mining industry as the
increasing frequency and extent of loadshedding and load curtailment measures disrupts operations. While we have been able to
mitigate the impact of load curtailment by re-scheduling energy intensive activities to lower demand periods, and have benefited from
extra capacity at our SA PGM processing operations, such measures are less effective during extended and frequent periods of
loadshedding.

As there are no immediate solutions to improve national energy security in South Africa, we are pursuing self-generation projects that will
improve the security of energy supply. We are also working with stakeholders to remove red tape and alleviate other obstacles such as
limited network access, with the aim of commissioning additional generation as quickly as possible. This is expected to reduce the risk of
this aspect of our operations, significantly decreasing our dependence on Eskom, and the carbon emissions attributable to a reliance on
Eskom's coal-fired generation, which dominate our current scope 2 emissions.

The successful production build up at the SA gold operations   in H2 2022 following the industrial action and lockout in the first half of 2022,
along with an appropriately structured wage agreement, which   was achieved as a consequence of the lockout, enabled a return to
profitability at the SA gold operations in the improved gold   price environment. The SA gold operations delivered a positive adjusted
EBITDA of R774 million (US$44 million) for Q1 2023, compared   with the adjusted EBITDA loss of R680 million (negative US$45 million) for Q1 2022.

Results from the SA PGM operations were steady, considering the more challenging macroeconomic and operating environment for Q1 2023
compared with Q1 2022. The 19% decline in the rand 4E PGM basket price to R36,433/4Eoz (US$2,051/4Eoz) and the production impact of increased
load curtailment by Eskom and heightened criminal activity, specifically related to copper theft, contributed to a 43% year-on-year decline
in adjusted EBITDA to R7.0 billion (US$391 million) from record adjusted EBITDA for Q1 2022 of R12.1 billion (US$798 million). PGM prices
were boosted to record levels during Q1 2022, due to the onset of the Ukraine hostilities. Despite the pullback in PGM prices, the AISC
margin for Q1 2023 remained robust at 46%* due to solid cost management at the operations. PGM prices have shown signs of recovery post
quarter end, which, supported by improving auto sales numbers recorded in March 2023, implies a more positive outlook for H2 2023.

The Stillwater West mine unfortunately suffered a shaft incident which has temporarily delayed execution of the repositioned plan for the
US PGM operations, but we are confident that our investment in development and initiatives to address skills shortages associated with the
challenging labour market in the US will materialise by the end of the year and have a sustainable impact. Costs have remained elevated
due to volume shortfalls related to the shaft incident and planned expenditure on ore reserve development (ORD) to improve operational flexibility.

The global economic slowdown resulted in lower automotive scrapping rates as consumers deferred new vehicle purchases, placing
continued pressure on the available feed for our US PGM recycling operations. Combined with the pressure on PGM commodity prices,
the adjusted EBITDA contribution from recycling continued to be suppressed in Q1 2023. With promising signs of an uptick in automotive
sales moving into the second half of 2023, feed rates are expected to normalise restoring the contribution to group earnings.

While the economic and operating outlook remains challenging and uncertain, we are beginning to identify early indications of more
positive sentiment after a very tough period. We continue to believe that we are well positioned to benefit from a more positive and
supportive environment and will continue to deliver shared value with all stakeholders.

*   The AISC margin is calculated by dividing the difference between AISC and underground plus surface revenue (revenue) by revenue

SAFE PRODUCTION

While Zero harm remains our ultimate objective, our immediate goal continues to focus on eliminating high-energy fatal and serious
incidents through our Fatal elimination strategy that comprises the key pillars of critical controls, critical life saving behaviours,
and critical management routines.

As noted earlier, the Group safety performance continued to improve during Q1 2023 with the Serious Injury Frequency Rate (SIFR)
improving by 17% year-on-year, from 3.06 for Q1 2022 to 2.53 for Q1 2023. This follows a 23% improvement in the SIFR for Q1 2022 relative to
Q1 2021, which is a pleasing outcome. Further evidence that the Fatal elimination strategy is achieving the desired results, is the 56%
decline in the Fatal Injury Frequency Rate (FIFR) from 0.055 for Q1 2022 to 0.024 for Q1 2023. Particular significant milestones achieved
during Q1 2023 were the SA PGM operations achieving 6 million fatality free shifts (FFS) on 15 March 2023 followed by the SA region
operations which achieved 8 million FFS on 28 March 2023.

The Group Total Recordable Injury Frequency Rate (TRIFR) increased by 1% from 5.42 (per million hours worked) for Q1 2022 to 5.49 for Q1
2023, but remained significantly better than the 7.84 achieved in Q1 2021. Similarly the Lost Day Injury Frequency Rate (LDIFR) showed a
slight regression, increasing by 4% from 4.62 in Q1 2022 to 4.79 in Q1 2023.

Regrettably, we lost one of our colleagues at the SA gold operations on the last day of Q1 2023. Mr Thabiso Ramotselisi, who worked as a
Locomotive Guard at Driefontein Pitseng shaft, was fatally injured in a rail bound equipment accident. Mr Ramotselisi was 41 years old
and is survived by his wife and two daughters. Our heartfelt condolences are extended to the family, friends and colleagues of our
deceased colleague. This incident has been thoroughly investigated together with the relevant stakeholders with support being provided
to Mr Ramotselisi's family and children. The rest of the Group's operations had a fatal free first quarter.

Post Q1 2023, (on 13 April 2023), a tragic incident occurred, at the Burnstone project, where a newly constructed surface waste rock
conveyor collapsed. The collapse occurred while five contractor employees were installing a head pulley of the conveyor infrastructure.
Tragically, four persons were fatally injured, while a fifth person sustained serious injuries and is currently receiving treatment.
The board and management of Sibanye-Stillwater extend their sincere condolences to the family, friends and colleagues of the deceased.
A full investigation into the cause of the incident is underway.

While the focus is on ongoing improvement in all aspects of safety, the primary focus during 2023, is to further implement and
operationalise the Fatal elimination strategy, to institutionalise the commitment and responsibility for safety among operational line
management and to all employees to mitigate high energy risks. We remain committed to the continuous improvement in health and
safety at our operations and we have enhanced our risk approach to make fatality prevention our main priority.

OPERATING REVIEW

US PGM operations

During March 2023, the Stillwater West mine suffered structural damage to the shaft which accesses the deeper levels of the mine. The
suspension of operations below 50 level during remediation of the shaft has temporarily delayed the repositioned plan and will result in
reduced production and elevated costs for 2023 relative to previous guidance. There were no injuries from this incident and the shaft was
successfully recommissioned on 16 April 2023, with production from below 50 level resuming and building-up to normalised levels by the
end of April 2023. The incident resulted in approximately 20,000 2Eoz less production from the Stillwater West mine for Q1 2023, with annual
production for 2023 expected to be reduced by approximately 30,000 2Eoz.

Primarily due to the incident, mined 2E PGM production from the US PGM operations of 100,690 2Eoz for Q1 2023 was 18% or 21,699 2Eoz
lower than for Q1 2022. Production from the Stillwater mine of 61,520 2Eoz for Q1 2023, was, 23% lower than the comparable period in 2022
as a result of the incident. The East Boulder mine produced 39,170 2Eoz, 8% lower than for Q1 2022, primarily due to persistent geological
and geotechnical complexity associated with mining to the western section of the mine, compounded by critical skills shortages, which
continue to affect productivity.

Development at the Stillwater mine was significantly impacted by the shaft incident, but continued above 50 level and at the East
Boulder mine throughout the period. Following the repositioning of the US PGM operations in mid-2022 and completion of the Benbow
decline development during 2022, project development at Stillwater East has been discontinued. Total development declined by 11% in
Q1 2023 to 5,821 meters compared to Q1 2022, with development at the Stillwater mine 17% lower year-on-year due to the above
mentioned factors. Development at the East Boulder mine increased by 7% year-on-year, in line with the planned increase in
development rates to increase operational flexibility at the US PGM operations.

AISC of US$1,861/2Eoz (R33,052/2Eoz) for Q1 2023 was elevated due to the production shortfall and higher ORD costs, which increased by
31% year-on-year to US$55 million (R976 million) and sustaining capital which increased by 89% year-on-year to US$21 million (R367 million),
following the reclassification of Stillwater East ORD and sustaining capital during 2022. This was exacerbated by general inflationary
pressures affecting the industry, and continued reliance on higher cost contractor labour due to the ongoing skills shortage.

Total capital expenditure for Q1 2023 increased by 18% year-on-year to US$87 million (R1.5 billion) due to the planned increase in ORD
and the increase in sustaining capital year-on-year. Growth project capital was 47% lower at US$11 million (R198 million) due to the
completion of the Benbow decline development during 2022 and the suspension of further growth capital at Stillwater East.

US PGM recycling operations

The global autocatalyst recycling market remained constrained due to the global economic downturn, recessionary concerns and
sustained inflationary pressures which suppressed consumer demand for new vehicles, with fewer vehicles scrapped and older vehicles
continuing in service for longer. A second factor that has affected recycling throughput relates to our principled approach for an assured
chain of custody for recycled material. This has resulted in our US recycling operations declining to accept material from certain sources
pending proof of authenticity. In this regard we worked with a global legal firm to develop a strengthened set of responsible sourcing
standards and framework within the London Platinum and Palladium Market (LPPM) and with our own Group responsible sourcing
governance standards. We continue to work with the International Precious Metals Institute to promote policies regarding the prevention
of catalytic theft, which is a growing challenge.

Reflecting these constraints, the US PGM recycling operations fed an average of 10.7 tonnes per day (tpd) of spent autocatalyst material
for Q1 2023, 55% lower than for Q1 2022. 3E ounces fed of 78,844 3Eoz, were 59% lower than the 190,871 3Eoz fed for Q1 2022. At the end
of Q1 2023, approximately 33 tonnes of recycle inventory was on hand, compared to 74 tonnes at the end of Q1 2022. PGM recycling
ounces sold declined by 46% to 79,405 3Eoz with the average basket price received for Q1 2023 of US$2,972/3Eoz 3% lower than for Q1 2022.

Recent auto sector statistics indicate a possible recovery in industry sales for 2023, with March 2023 auto sales reflecting an annual sales
run rate of 92.5 million vehicles globally. China's economy is also showing signs of impending recovery, with GDP growth for Q1 2023 of
4.5%, the strongest in over a year. Continuation of these positive economic trends would support an improvement in recycling rates in H2 2023.

SA PGM operations

Total 4E PGM production of 403,699 4Eoz for Q1 2023 (including third party purchase of concentrate (PoC)) was only 4% lower than for Q1
2022, despite a more challenging operating environment than a year ago. Lower underground production of 344,052 4Eoz (7% lower
year-on-year) and surface production (excluding PoC) of 35,739 4Eoz, (12% lower), was partially offset by third party purchase of
concentrate (PoC), which increased by 124% to 23,908 4Eoz due to higher concentrate deliveries from third parties.

4E PGM production (excluding PoC) of 379,791 oz, was 8% lower year-on-year, primarily due to the ongoing planned closure and ceasing
of production at Simunye shaft at Kroondal, copper theft related production disruptions (5,200 4Eoz impact), load curtailment (5,120 4Eoz
impact) and productivity constraints in areas where operations are mining through adverse ground conditions (4,100 4Eoz impact).

Considering the decline in production including the planned Simunye shaft closure, the inclusion of the K4 project ORD costs at the
Marikana operation and general mining inflation for 2022 which exceeded 14%, AISC was well managed during the quarter. AISC
(excluding PoC) for Q1 2023 increased by 12% year-on-year to R20,043/4Eoz (US$1,129/4Eoz), with AISC for Q1 2023 (including PoC)
increasing by 11% year-on-year to R20,686/4Eoz (US$1,165/4Eoz). The increase in Q1 2023 AISC compared to Q1 2022, reflects a 68%
increase in ORD (R262 million (US$11 million) higher) due to ORD costs from the K4 project which were capitalised in Q1 2022, being
incorporated with ORD from the Marikana operations, resulting in a 98% year-on-year increase in Marikana ORD. AISC for Q1 2023, also
reflected lower royalties paid relative to Q1 2022 (64% lower or R410 million (US$29 million)) and 10% higher by-product credits
(R200 million (US$7 million) higher year-on-year).

4E PGM production from the Rustenburg operation for Q1 2023 of 147,484 oz was only 1% lower year-on-year, despite the impact of load
curtailment and ongoing cable theft. Underground production of 130,123 4Eoz was in line with Q1 2022 with surface production 8% lower
than Q1 2022. The Bathopele mine has now successfully traversed the Hexriver fault, and, while experiencing difficult ground conditions,
production is expected to normalise during H2 2023. AISC of R18,558/4Eoz (US$1,045/4Eoz) for Q1 2023 was 7% lower year-on-year due to
various factors including: royalties declining by 92% to R29 million (US$2 million), R336 million lower than Q1 2022, due to a royalty tax
reduction linked to the final Anglo Platinum deferred payment, which was made in Q1 2023 and increased by-product credits which were
28% higher at R847 million (US$48 million), R184 million higher than Q1 2022, (primarily due to higher chrome prices), partially offset by an
18% increase in ORD to R168 million (US$9 milion).

4E PGM production from the Marikana operation (including PoC) declined by 2% to 175,530 oz, due to a 124% increase in PoC ounces,
which partly offset lower production from underground and surface. The Marikana operation was impacted more by cable theft relative
to the other SA PGM operations, which together with load curtailment and safety stoppages, resulted in production (excluding PoC)
declining 10% year-on-year to 151,622 4Eoz. Production from underground of 146,346 4Eoz was 10% lower year-on-year, with surface
production of 5,276 4Eoz 20% lower. AISC (excluding PoC) increased by 29% to R23,057/4Eoz (US$1,298/4Eoz) with AISC (including PoC) of
R24,030/4Eoz (US$1,353/4Eoz), 24% higher year-on-year. While the K4 project remains in build up phase, elevated ORD costs, coupled with
low, but ramping up production output is increasing AISC at Marikana.

The Kroondal operation performed largely in line with its expectations with production of 41,187 4Eoz, 17% lower than for Q1 2022. This was
primarily due to the scheduled closure of the Simunye shaft at the end of 2022 (accounting for 75% of the year-on-year decline) and
continued adverse ground conditions at some Kroondal shafts which negatively affected productivity. In addition, AISC of R17,311/4Eoz
(US$975/4Eoz) was 16% higher than for Q1 2022 as a result of lower production (with Simunye still carrying overhead costs, which will be
transferred to other operations in future), inflationary effects highlighted above and additional underground support required for the
adverse ground conditions, in particular the Eastern shafts which are mining through a shear zone.

While PGM production from Platinum Mile in Q1 2023 of 13,102 4Eoz was 13% lower compared to Q1 2022, this was in line with
expectations considering lower production from mining of the current horizons and noting that additional surface tonnes were added to
the flotation output from the Rustenburg concentrator resulting in a temporary boost to the yield in the prior period. In addition, load
curtailment impacted treatment of ore at the UG2 and retro concentrators. The decrease in output and general inflationary costs
pressures coupled with higher sustaining capital, resulted in higher AISC of R10,456/4Eoz (US$589/4Eoz).

Attributable PGM production from Mimosa for Q1 2023 of 26,396 4Eoz was 6% lower than for Q1 2022. Milling operations at Mimosa were
negatively impacted by sporadic regional power interruptions and a planned five-day plant shutdown in March 2023 to integrate and
commission the optimised plant project. The focus at Mimosa remains on optimising the reagent suite and cell settings across the flotation
circuit. AISC in Q1 2023 was 49% higher year-on-year at US$1,372/4Eoz (R24,360/4Eoz) due to lower production, and sustaining capital
which increased by 80% to US$13 million (R237 million). Increased sustaining capital was as a result of spending on the process plant
optimisation, expansion of the concentrator capacity, and a new tailings storage facility (TSF) as the existing TSF is reaching capacity.

Q1 2023 chrome sales of 499k tonnes were 22% lower than sales of 640k tonnes for Q1 2022, due to logistics timing for Rustenburg and
lower production from Marikana. Chrome revenue of R852 million (US$48 million) for Q1 2023 was 29% higher than Q1 2022, due to lower
sales offset by the chrome price received increasing by 44% to US$283/tonne from US$196/tonne in Q1 2022.

Capital expenditure for Q1 2023 of R1,161 million (US$65 million) increased by 19% compared to Q1 2022, largely due to an increase in
ORD at the Marikana K4 project.

SA gold operations

The SA managed gold operations are benefitting from an appropriately structured, inflation linked wage agreement settled in 2022 which
positions the Group well for the record gold price recorded in early May 2023.

Production from the SA gold operations (including DRDGOLD) for Q1 2023 of 6,229kg (200,267oz) was 46% higher than for Q1 2022,
following the resumption of the operations after the industrial action in the first half of 2022. Gold production (excluding DRDGOLD) of
4,900kg (157,539oz) increased by 71% compared to Q1 2022.

AISC (including DRDGOLD) for Q1 2023 of R1,042,868/kg (US$1,826/oz) and AISC (excluding DRDGOLD) of R1,109,088/kg (US$1,942/oz) was
significantly improved on the previous comparable quarter and year, reflecting a return towards normalised operations from significant
operational disruptions during 2022. Load curtailment continues to challenge normal operating procedures and causes an increase in
operating costs, but is being managed through the adoption of more effective protocols to mitigate impact.

Capital expenditure for Q1 2023 (excluding DRDGOLD) of R1,227 million (US$69 million) reflected the normalisation of operations and
resumption of the Burnstone project.

The Driefontein operation delivered a strong performance for the quarter with tonnes milled increasing since the strike and and yield
increasing since Q4 2022 as higher grade panels are accessed. Underground production increased by 31% to 1,844kg (59,286oz) year-on-
year following the recovery from the strike. Surface production at 59kg (1,897oz) was 25% lower because of a steady depletion of
payable surface material in line with the long-term plan. AISC of R1,065,837/kg (US$1,867/oz) was 1% lower than for Q1 2022. Sustaining
capital expenditure increased by 31% to R80 million (US$5 million) mainly due to higher expenditure on the D4 pillar project which will
open up new high grade reef. ORD increased by 38% to R349 million (US$20 million) in line with the increase in off-reef development
meters achieved.

Kloof underground production of 1,644kg (52,856oz) in Q1 2023 was 65% higher year-on-year with the underground yield increasing by
17% due to improved mining quality. Production from surface sources of 88kg (2,829oz), was 53% lower year-on-year due to depletion of
the available surface rock dumps as per the budget plan. AISC of R1,213,050/kg (US$2,124/oz) in Q1 2023 was 17% lower than for Q1 2022
due to higher production. Sustaining capital was 26% lower year-on-year due to lower expenditure on winder upgrades and plant
refurbishment projects with ORD capital 19% higher primarily due to the normalisation of off-reef development post industrial action.
Project capital at the Kloof 4 shaft deepening project decreased by 11% to R31 million (US$2 million).

Underground gold production from the Beatrix operation for Q1 2023 of 957kg (30,768oz) increased from 37kg (1,190oz) in Q1 2022 with
production from surface sources increasing from 9kg (289oz) to 48kg (1,543oz). AISC declined by 75% year-on-year to R1,033,135/kg
(US$1,809/oz) due to the significant increase in gold sold, offset by inflationary cost increases as described above and ORD increasing by
168% to R83 million (US$5 million).

Section 189 consultations with stakeholders were concluded during Q1 2023, with operations at the Beatrix 4 shaft and Kloof 1 plant
subsequently ceased. The Beatrix 4 shaft previously contributed approximately 20% of production from the Beatrix operation, and
production and grade from the Beatrix operation will be reduced going forward although improved profitability is anticipated due to the
cessation of loss making production.

Surface gold production from Cooke operations in Q1 2023 increased by 64% to 260kg (8,359oz) with AISC increasing by 8% to R983,713/
kg (US$1,723/oz) when compared to Q1 2022 due to 61% increase in cost of sales as a result of the above inflation increases on
chemicals and steel balls as well as the increase in aggregate purchase price which is linked to the higher gold price received in
terms of tolling agreements.

Gold production from DRDGOLD of 1,329kg (42,728oz) for Q1 2023, was 4% lower than for Q1 2022 due to a 21% decrease in tons milled
partly offset by a 19% increase in yield to 0.25g/t. The decrease in the tonnes milled is a result of the reclamation of final remnant and
clean up of material at operating sites nearing depletion, with the increase in yield associated with higher grade remnant material that is
typically encountered during the final stages of reclamation and clean up. AISC in Q1 2023 increased by 8% to 772,009/kg (US$1,352/oz)
due to lower gold sold, industry inflationary effects and a 44% increase in sustaining capital required for development of new reclamation
sites to replace operating sites nearing depletion. Project capital increased by 596% in Q1 2023 year-on-year to R160 million (US$9 million),
primarily on the development of the solar power plant project.

SA gold Burnstone project

The Burnstone project schedule was negatively impacted by the industrial action in 2022, combined with a shortage of skills and trackless
mobile machinery. The project scope has been amended to incorporate these constraints, with initial production from Burnstone now
expected in 2024. Pleasingly, early works on the metallurgical plant have commenced in line with schedule and the integrated water use
license application (IWULA) will be re-submitted to the Department of Water and Sanitation in June 2023 after addressing queries raised
by the regulators. During Q1 2023 project capital of R373 million (US$21 million) was incurred. This was below planned capital, primarily as
a result of lower ORD, weather delays and load shedding impact on the availability of electrical equipment.

The tragic conveyor incident at Burnstone in April 2023 is likely to cause a delay in completion of the shaft rock handling system by about
four months. The full impact of the incident has yet to be determined.

European region - Sandouville operations

The acquisition of the Sandouville nickel refinery in Le Havre, France was concluded on 4 February 2022 and therefore comparing the
operational results for Q1 2023 with Q1 2022 should be seen in this context. The tough H2 2022 where technical issues in the cathode
production unit affected the overall performance continued into Q1 2023. The Q4 2022 start-up after the annual maintenance shutdown
in October took longer than expected. Q1 2023 saw an improved performance on Q4 2022.

However, Q1 2023 was still challenging, with the breakdown of the cathode plant in late 2022 continuing into Q1 2023. Although most of
the cathode cells had been repaired by the end of March 2023, the lack of full availability has throttled production. It is expected that the
plant will reach full production in Q3 2023. Production in Q1 2023 was also impacted by 32 days of lost production due to French national
strikes, plant reliability and process issues.

Sandouville produced 1,180 tonnes of nickel metal in Q1 2023 (5% lower than *Q1 2022), 429 tonnes of nickel salts (8% higher than *Q1
2022) and 33 tonnes of cobalt chloride (6% lower than *Q1 2022) at a nickel equivalent sustaining cost of US$38,750/tNi (R688,196/tNi), 10%
higher than Q1 2022. Unit costs were primarily impacted by production constraints as well as higher energy and raw material inputs.
Sustaining capital of US$2 million (R44 million) in Q1 2023 was 277% higher than for *Q1 2022 of US$1 million (R10 million) with increased
expenditure on plant maintenance to achieve stability offset by-product credits which increased by 157% to US$3 million (R45 million).

A number of new management appointments were made in Q1 2023 including: Head of France, Chief technical officer and Sandouville
financial manager and a turnaround plan was initiated focussed on cost analysis, adapting product mix to market requirements, plant
recoveries and reliability.

Feasibility studies continue on the PGM autocatalyst recycling, battery grade nickel sulphate and battery metals recycling projects.

*   Note that Sibanye-Stillwater acquired the Sandouville nickel refinery on 4 February 2021 and therefore amounts included for Q1 2022
    are from the effective date of acquisition.

Keliber

As announced on 6 Feb 2023, Keliber received the environmental permit for the Rapasaari mine and Paivaneva concentrator from the
Regional State Administrative Agency for Western and Inland Finland (AVI). Keliber carefully assessed the 144 permit conditions the permit
contained and made a submission to the Vaasa Administrative Court for changes to and/or clarification to six of the permit conditions.
Keliber continues to engage and provide information to the court process at Vaasa Administrative Court after two external appeals were
lodged. As announced on 25 April 2023, the Finnish Minerals Group, which represents and manages the Finnish State's mining industry
investments, confirmed its support for the project increasing its holding in the Keliber project from 14% to 20% by subscribing for
EUR53.9 million of the EUR104 million rights issue.

Further developments

-   The commencement of the earthworks for the Keliber lithium refinery (first phase of the Keliber lithium project) in Kokkola, Finland
    began on 7 March 2023 with the foundation stone planned to be laid during a ceremony on 11 May 2023
-   Contractors signed on to provide earthworks and foundations for the lithium refinery as well as a contract management service provider
-   Several procurement agreements and other contracts signed
-   Negotiations advancing with a syndicate of banks for debt financing of the remaining project capital post conclusion of the EUR104 million
    rights issue
-   107 people on site including 73 contractors
-   29 exploration holes drilled with three drill rigs totalling 6,958 metres (a new quarterly record) with excellent intercepts at the
    Tuoreetsaaret, Rapasaari and Syvajarvi targets. As part of the regional lithium exploration a 7 week percussion drilling campaign conducted
-   Total capital expenditure estimate for the project remains unchanged at EUR588 million (R11.2 billion) with EUR177 million (R3.4 billion)
    already committed
     - Capital expenditure spent in Q1 2023 was EUR16.3 million (R311 million) with total capital expenditure spent to date EUR37.1 million
        (R707 million)
     - Capital expenditure spend marginally behind schedule due to slower than anticipated start of construction
-   Capital expenditure estimate for the lithium refinery remains unchanged at EUR359 million (R6.8 billion)
     - Capital expenditure spent in Q1 2023 EUR13.9 million (R265 million) with capital expenditure spent to date EUR31.7 million
        (R604 million)

OPERATING GUIDANCE FOR 2023*

Primarily as a result of the impact of the shaft incident at the Stillwater West mine, along with ongoing operational constraints
impacting the US PGM operations, guidance for 2023 has been revised. 2E PGM production for 2023 is now forecast to be between 460,000
2Eoz and 480,000 2Eoz, with AISC of between US$1,550/2Eoz to US$1,650/2Eoz. Capital expenditure is forecast to be between
US$285 million and US$300 million, including approximately US$25 million project capital.

3E PGM production for the US PGM recycling operations is forecast to be between 450,000 and 500,000 3Eoz fed for the year. Capital
expenditure is forecast at US$2.6 million (R41.9 million).

Forecast 4E PGM production from the SA PGM operations for 2023 remains unchanged at between 1.7M 4Eoz and 1.8M 4Eoz including
approximately 60,000 4Eoz of third party PoC, with AISC between R20,800/4Eoz and R21,800/4Eoz (US$1,300/4Eoz and US$1,363/4Eoz) -
excluding cost of third party PoC. Capital expenditure is forecast at R5.4 billion (US$338 million)* for the year, including project
capital of R920 million (US$58 million) on the K4 project.

Gold production from the managed SA gold operations (excluding DRDGOLD) for 2023 is forecast at between 23,500kg (756koz) and
24,500kg (788koz). This guidance reflects a return to normalised rates of production following the industrial action in 2022 but excludes
production from Beatrix 4 shaft and Kloof plant 1, where operations ceased during Q1 2023 following the conclusion of a successful
Section 189 consultation. While guidance currently remains unchanged, the company is undertaking a detailed technical review of
marginal operations considering operational and power constraints as well as sustained high levels of inflation. This review is expected to
be completed during the second quarter of 2023. AISC is forecast to be between R950,000/kg and R1,020,000/kg (US$1,882/oz and
US$1,940/oz). Capital expenditure is forecast at R5.9 billion (US$369 million), including R1.95 billion (US$122 million) of project capital
expenditure provided for the Burnstone project and R150 million (US$9 million) on the Kloof 4 deepening project.

Production from the Sandouville nickel refinery is forecast at between 9.5 and 10.1 kilotonnes of nickel product, at a Nickel equivalent
sustaining cost of EUR24,813/t (R409k/t)* and capital expenditure of EUR15.9million (R262.9million)*. Capital expenditure at the
Keliber lithium project for 2023 is forecast to be about EUR231million (R3.81 billion)*.
*   The guidance has been translated where relevant at an average exchange rate of R16.00/US$ and R16.50/EUR

SALIENT FEATURES AND COST BENCHMARKS - QUARTERS

US and SA PGM operations

                                                                US PGM
                                                    US and      opera-            Total SA
                                                    SA PGM       tions        PGM operations(1)           Rustenburg            Marikana(1)     Kroondal      Plat     Mimosa
                                                     opera       Under             Under               Under                   Under            Attribu-      Mile   Attribu-
                                                  tions(1)   ground(2)    Total   ground Surface      ground Surface          ground Surface        able   Surface      table
Production
Tonnes milled/     000't             Mar   2023      8,742        282      8,460     3,860    4,600     1,412     1,260        1,436      812       686     2,529        326
treated                              Dec   2022      9,242        286      8,956     4,229    4,727     1,399     1,385        1,660      892       823     2,450        347
                                     Mar   2022      9,291        328      8,963     4,131    4,832     1,420     1,422        1,538      928       833     2,482        340
Plant head grade   g/t               Mar   2023       2.29      12.26       1.96      3.28     0.85      3.34      1.05         3.64    0.88       2.27      0.74       3.53
                                     Dec   2022       2.31      12.60       1.98      3.27     0.82      3.31      1.08         3.62    0.86       2.40      0.66       3.53
                                     Mar   2022       2.38      12.74       2.00      3.29     0.89      3.29      1.11         3.78    0.85       2.28      0.77       3.57
Plant recoveries   %                 Mar   2023      74.64      90.67      71.24     84.52    28.43     85.81     40.83        87.08   22.98      82.28     21.77      71.33
                                     Dec   2022      75.42      91.20      72.30     84.94    27.20     86.22     33.77        86.75   26.01      82.43     21.62      74.39
                                     Mar   2022      75.15      90.08      71.42     84.74    29.35     86.66     37.18        86.96   25.87      81.09     24.65      71.86
Yield              g/t               Mar   2023       1.71      11.12       1.40      2.77     0.24      2.87      0.43         3.17    0.20       1.87      0.16       2.52
                                     Dec   2022       1.74      11.49       1.43      2.78     0.22      2.85      0.36         3.14    0.22       1.98      0.14       2.63
                                     Mar   2022       1.79      11.48       1.43      2.79     0.26      2.85      0.41         3.29    0.22       1.85      0.19       2.57
PGM production(3) 4Eoz - 2Eoz        Mar   2023    480,481    100,690    379,791   344,052   35,739   130,123    17,361      146,346   5,276     41,187    13,102     26,396
                                     Dec   2022    516,720    105,205    411,515   377,627   33,888   128,351    16,236      167,645   6,413     52,321    11,239     29,310
                                     Mar   2022    533,237    122,389    410,848   370,272   40,576   130,171    18,870      162,540   6,562     49,518    15,144     28,043
PGM sold(4)        4Eoz - 2Eoz       Mar   2023    500,257     87,781    412,476                      135,514    20,466           180,929        41,187    13,102     21,278
                                     Dec   2022    523,756    110,822    412,934                      150,266    19,061           152,402        52,321    11,239     27,645
                                     Mar   2022    563,328    111,153    452,175                      155,095    17,167           187,611        49,518    15,144     27,640
Price and costs(5)
Average PGM
basket price(6)    R/4Eoz - R/2Eoz   Mar 2023       34,357     25,326    36,433                       36,952     27,855            36,988        38,142    29,968     30,406
                                     Dec 2022       39,418     30,608    41,953                       42,625     30,156            42,446        44,636    33,775     33,279
                                     Mar 2022       42,210     31,323    45,061                       46,559     29,993            45,007        48,327    36,793     34,514

Average PGM        US$/4Eoz -
basket price(6)    US$/2Eoz          Mar 2023       1,935       1,426     2,051                        2,081     1,568              2,083         2,148     1,687      1,712
                                     Dec 2022       2,238       1,738     2,382                        2,420     1,712              2,410         2,535     1,918      1,890
                                     Mar 2022       2,773       2,058     2,961                        3,059     1,971              2,957         3,175     2,417      2,268

Operating cost(7) R/t                Mar 2023       1,159       7,665       934                        2,042        143             1,589          1,180       60      1,653
                                     Dec 2022       1,140       7,838       918                        2,072        300             1,366          1,154       61      1,553
                                     Mar 2022         977       5,704       797                        1,820        155             1,277            945       53      1,203

Operating cost(7) US$/t              Mar 2023          65         432        53                          115            8              89            66         3         93
                                     Dec 2022          65         445        52                          118           17              78            66         3         88
                                     Mar 2022          64         375        52                          120           10              84            62         3         79

Operating cost(7) R/4Eoz - R/2Eoz    Mar 2023       21,476     21,432    21,489                       22,156      0,368            23,552        19,642    11,525     20,420
                                     Dec 2022       20,812     21,320    20,672                       22,587     25,622            20,034        18,138    13,346     18,390
                                     Mar 2022       17,306     15,287    17,952                       19,858     11,659            18,616        15,893     8,716     14,585

Operating          US$/4Eoz -        Mar 2023        1,209      1,207      1,210                        1,248          584          1,326          1,106       649     1,150
cost(7)            US$/2Eoz
                                     Dec 2022        1,182      1,211     1,174                        1,283      1,455             1,138         1,030       758      1,044
                                     Mar 2022        1,137      1,004     1,179                        1,305        766             1,223         1,044       573        958

All-in sustaining R/4Eoz - R/2Eoz    Mar 2023      22,927      33,052    20,043                            18,558                  23,057        17,311    10,456     24,360
cost(8)                              Dec 2022      24,066      32,613    21,713                            23,543                  22,257        16,819    12,457     24,053
                                     Mar 2022      18,142      18,940    17,886                            20,041                  17,806        14,863     7,462     13,979
                   US$/4Eoz -
All-in             US$/2Eoz          Mar 2023       1,291       1,861     1,129                                1,045                1,298           975       589      1,372
sustaining cost(8)                   Dec 2022       1,367       1,852     1,233                                1,337                1,264           955       707       1366
                                     Mar 2022       1,192       1,244     1,175                                1,317                1,170           977       490        918
All-in cost(8)    R/4Eoz - R/2Eoz      Mar 2023     23,725      35,018     20,507                         18,558             24,132           17,336   10,456     24,360
                                       Dec 2022     25,492      36,234     22,535                         23,536             24,067           16,819   12,457     24,053
                                       Mar 2022     19,177      21,546     18,419                         20,041             19,012           14,863    7,462     13,979
                  US$/4Eoz -
All-in cost(8)    US$/2Eoz             Mar 2023     1,336       1,972      1,155                           1,045              1,359             976       589     1,372
                                       Dec 2022     1,448       2,058      1,280                           1,337              1,367             955       707     1,366
                                       Mar 2022     1,260       1,416      1,210                           1,317              1,249             977       490       918

Capital expenditure(5)
Ore reserve       R'mil                Mar   2023   1,622         976          646                            168               478                -          -        -
development                            Dec   2022   1,481         887          594                            178               416                -          -        -
                                       Mar   2022   1,021         637          384                            142               242                -          -        -
Sustaining        R'mil                Mar   2023     718         367          351                            128               168               48          7      237
capital
                                       Dec   2022   1,288         513        775                              245               439              78        13       313
                                       Mar   2022     552         166        386                              156               183              46         1       113
Corporate         R'mil                Mar   2023     362         198        164                                -               163               1         -         -
and projects                           Dec   2022     692         381        311                              (1)               312               -         -         -
                                       Mar   2022     523         319        204                                -               204               -         -         -
Total capital     R'mil                Mar   2023   2,702       1,541      1,161                              296               809              49         7       237
expenditure                            Dec   2022   3,461       1,781      1,680                              422             1,167              78        13       313
                                       Mar   2022   2,096       1,122        974                              298               629              46         1       113
Total capital     US$'mil              Mar   2023     152          87         65                               17                46               3         -        13
expenditure                            Dec   2022     197         101         95                               24                66               4         1        18
                                       Mar   2022     138          74         64                               20                41               3         -         7

Average exchange rate for the quarters ended 31 March 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 March 2022 was R17.76/US$, R17.61/US$ and R15.22/US$, respectively

Figures may not add as they are rounded independently

(1) The US and SA PGM operations, Total SA PGM operations and Marikana excludes the production and costs associated with the purchase of
    concentrate (PoC) from third parties. For a reconciliation of the Operating cost, AISC and AIC excluding third party PoC, refer to
    "Reconciliation of operating cost excluding third party PoC for US and SA PGM operations, Total SA PGM operations and Marikana - Quarters" and
    "Reconciliation of AISC and AIC excluding third party PoC for US and SA PGM operations, Total SA PGM operations and Marikana - Quarters"
(2) The US PGM operations' underground production is converted to metric tonnes and kilograms, and performance is translated into rand. In addition
    to the US PGM operations' underground production, the operation treats various recycling material which is excluded from the statistics shown
    above and is detailed in the PGM recycling table below
(3) Production per product - see prill split in the table below
(4) PGM sold includes the third party PoC ounces sold
(5) The US and SA PGM operations and total SA PGM operations' unit cost benchmarks and capital expenditure exclude the financial results of Mimosa,
    which is equity accounted and excluded from revenue and cost of sales
(6) The average PGM basket price is the PGM revenue per 4E/2E ounce, prior to a purchase of concentrate adjustment
(7) Operating cost is the average cost of production and operating cost per tonne is calculated by dividing the cost of sales, before amortisation
    and depreciation and change in inventory in a period by the tonnes milled/treated in the same period, and operating cost per ounce (and kilogram)
    is calculated by dividing the cost of sales, before amortisation and depreciation and change in inventory in a period, by the PGM produced in
    the same period. For a reconciliation, refer to "Unit operating cost - Quarters" US and SA PGM operations
(8) All-in cost is calculated in accordance with the World Gold Council guidance. All-in cost excludes income tax, costs associated with merger and
    acquisition activities, working capital,impairments, financing costs, one-time severance charges and items needed to normalise earnings. All-in
    cost is made up of All-in sustaining cost, being the cost to sustain current operations, given as a sub-total in the All-in cost calculation,
    together with corporate and major capital expenditure associated with growth. All-in sustaining cost per ounce (and kilogram) and All-in cost
    per ounce (and kilogram) are calculated by dividing the All-in sustaining cost and All-in cost, respectively, in a period by the total 4E/2E
    PGM produced in the same period. For a reconciliation of cost of sales before amortisation and depreciation to All-in costs,
    see "All-in costs - Quarters"

Mining - PGM Prill split including third party PoC, excluding recycling operations

                                     US AND SA PGM OPERATIONS                                       TOTAL SA PGM OPERATIONS                                    US PGM OPERATIONS
                          ...